The Great British Bake Off: Biscuit Week
September 5, 2017 9:57 PM - Season 8, Episode 2 - Subscribe

Sandwich Biscuits, Fortune Cookies and a Biscuit Board Game!
posted by GuyZero (15 comments total) 2 users marked this as a favorite
 
The real question is whether Operation is a board game.
posted by GuyZero at 9:57 PM on September 5


Noel seems to be warming up nicely and chemistry seems to be slowly developing along the hosts judges and bakers. I miss the old Team, but this is fine. Partly it's the well chosen bakers who keep it aloft.

I always get fond of the charming and talented, slightly kooky bakers who are just a bit too erratic to reach the final. So far, I like Yan and Liam. Flo is good TV but not long for the tent I fear. Steven and Sophie are highly promising.

I get the sense that they've upped the challenge level to avoid the accusation that it's been "dumbed down" for Channel 4. The time for the Showstopper seemed very very short!
posted by NoiselessPenguin at 2:23 AM on September 6


I can't say how relieved I am to find the show format essentially intact, in spite of the loss of Mary, Sue, and Mel. The differences are still a bit jarring, but it turns out that as long as they don't muck with the music, it still feels like GBBO to me. I'm having a little bit of trouble warming up to Sandi, but Noel is unexpectedly lovely and I like Prue very much.

This seems like a very cordial group of bakers, even by the standards of the show. The moment when *three* bakers stepped in to help Tom finish his Signature in time was so heartwarming, and I love how vigorously they're cheering each other on after the judging.

Steven is definitely an early fave (I find his incredulity at his own success very touching) and I don't know that I'm going to get to enjoy him for long, but Liam is a total sweetheart. Anyone else having trouble telling Kate and Sophie apart? I know Sophie's hair has been in a braid for the first couple of episodes, but I still keep having to remind myself which is which!
posted by merriment at 5:04 AM on September 6


I'm struggling with telling them apart too. I also this year for the first time having a hard time understanding some accents. I'm glad they didn't ruin it in some horrible way as this show is so comforting. It shows what is really missing in the reality world - people actually being helpful and cheering for each other and not getting into drama. I can't think of one American or Canadian show that has groups of people like it. I love shows that are ultimately based on someone making something. The closest American ones I can stand are Top Chef and Project Runway (ignoring all the drama in that one gets harder)

It also has shown me by food bias because it seems that rose is such a common flavour in the UK but peanut butter isn't (thinking past seasons).
posted by kanata at 11:41 AM on September 6 [1 favorite]


I kept wishing that someone would do Catan! Lots of hexagon cookies (sorry, biscuits), and then some nice little thin ones for the roads and houses and such. But I guess copyright would've been an issue? (See also: "The Jungle Game").

I continue to cackle gleefully whenever Yan is on screen, and am just thoroughly enjoying this batch of contestants in general (A stunt double in training! A amateur blacksmith! Flo dancing with her friends to "All About that Bass"!).
posted by damayanti at 11:56 AM on September 6


Flo is ADORABLE but must confess that I can't understand most of what she says!
posted by merriment at 12:32 PM on September 6


I'm having a little bit of trouble warming up to Sandi, but Noel is unexpectedly lovely and I like Prue very much.

My wife said the same thing about Sandi last night. I've watched her on a number of things over the years, and she's quite funny usually, but it seems like she's been asked/told to play it down a notch. I also like Prue, though I gather that the bit where she spat out the half-baked biscuit caused quite the stir among British Twitterers as "Our Mary would never have done that!"
posted by briank at 1:17 PM on September 6


Was also hoping for Catan but to have it be fully playable, I suppose they'd technically need to replicate the decks of cards. Something like Carcassonne would work well.

On licensing, operation is copyright by Hasbro..

After "you will mostly poo candyfloss", I was kinda expecting to see Noel playing Meeple Circus.
posted by joeyh at 6:50 PM on September 6


Battleship would be a *great* game for this format. You get to eat the ships you sink..
posted by joeyh at 6:52 PM on September 6


If only one of the bakers had been a Warhammer 40K enthusiast we could have been treated to a battle scene of edible Space Marines and Chaos Daemons. ICING FOR THE ICING GOD!!
posted by Major Clanger at 1:32 PM on September 7 [3 favorites]


Sandwich Biscuits, Fortune Cookies and a Biscuit Board Game!

I for one see a glaring omission here.
posted by ricochet biscuit at 6:01 AM on September 8


*not ricochet biscuit-ist
posted by merriment at 3:36 PM on September 8


More goddamn fondant "frosting". I'VE GOT YOUR FONDANT RIGHT HERE *gesticulates rudely*.

Otherwise, yeah, it's settling in nicely. I worry that at least one or two of the Meet The Bakers segments has felt a bit like they've slipped a ringer into the competition. I forget who it was, but they had someone working in front of a far-too-nice wedding cake and not the usual "look, Albert here likes to make baked goods for his council meetings, he's also an avid turnip breeder."
posted by Kyol at 8:25 AM on September 11


(which, I should clarify before I come off as fondant-ist - fondant as an alternative to marzipan where the baker wants to make small decorative touches that hold their shape? Fine, OK. But as a way to hide all the blemishes of a baked good under a silky smooth fondant layer? bzzt. It's cheap and hacky. You get some minor points for making your own, but not much.)
posted by Kyol at 8:38 AM on September 11


I liked Noel before he joined the show (I love The Mighty Boosh), so he has a bit of an advantage in terms of me getting behind the new hosts. Sandi, isn't really zinging for me and their partnership doesn't come anywhere close to the fantastic chemistry of Mel and Sue.

The playable board game challenge seemed like a fun idea, though I think it would have been better later in the season.
posted by Julnyes at 12:22 PM on September 14


« Older SGU Stargate Universe: Human...   |  Podcast: Within the Wires: Sea... Newer »

You are not logged in, either login or create an account to post comments

poster